By Bigg Success Staff
Bigg Success with Money
This is one of the most frequently-asked questions we get here at Bigg Success. The question comes in a variety of forms:
Should you make a payment every four weeks? Should you include a little extra with every payment? Or perhaps, you’ve had a windfall and wonder – should you pay it off in its entirety?
9 questions to determine if you should pay off your mortgage early
#1 – Do you have any other debt?
It’s highly likely that you pay less, after taxes, for your mortgage than you pay for any other debt. So pay that debt off before you start funneling additional money into your mortgage.
Look at it this way – you could put your money into an account that pays a guaranteed 20% after taxes or one that guarantees a 5% return after taxes. That’s an easy decision, isn’t it? You’re going to invest in the guaranteed 20%!
When you pay off debt, your return equals your after-tax interest cost. So pay off accounts that cost you the most first.
#2 – Do you have an emergency reserve?
Financial planners disagree on exactly how much you should have in reserve for emergencies. However, there seems to be a consensus of between three and twelve months of living expenses.
It depends somewhat on the source of your income. How secure is it? A stable job with a stable employer (is there such a thing these days?) means you need less of a reserve. For business owners and commissioned sales people, twelve months may serve you best.
#3 – How good is your credit rating?
Depending on how you do it, paying your mortgage off faster is great unless you end up with a month where you’re short on cash. Then you’ll hurt your credit rating. So consider building up money into a separate account that you use to pay your mortgage. As that account accumulates extra money, pay a little more on your mortgage.
At its essence, paying down your mortgage early is an investment in a very illiquid asset. If you don’t have good credit, you may be restricted in getting a home equity line-of-credit should the need arise. You’ll be better off building up your reserve account before you start paying down your mortgage.
#4 – How do you feel about debt?
Some people just can’t be happy as long as they have any debt. If you’re one of those people, and you’re satisfied with your answer to the previous three questions, by all means pay off your mortgage early.
If you have enough cash sitting around to pay it off in full, do it! If that’s not the case, start plowing any additional money you have into it. You’ll feel better just seeing your outstanding balance going down faster.
#5 – What’s your interest rate?
That last question considers your personal psychology. There’s no right or wrong – it’s solely your attitude.
If you can live with debt, then you look at this decision solely from the financial point-of-view – what’s your best financial move? Start by looking at your interest rate:
- What’s the stated interest rate in your mortgage contract?
- How much will you pay in income taxes on the next dollar you earn (i.e. your marginal tax rate)?
You’ll end up with the after-tax cost of your mortgage. Now you’re ready for the next three questions.
#6 – How disciplined are you?
How well do you do with extra money? If you tend to spend it, you’ll probably be better off paying off your mortgage early. That guarantees you the after-tax return you just calculated in the previous question.
However, if you’re a good money manager, your options are still open. Look at the next two questions.
#7 – When do you plan to retire?
Time is a wonderful thing. The longer your horizon, the higher your return will likely be on your portfolio if you invest correctly. That’s because you can invest in assets that may be more volatile in the short-run, but provide higher returns in the long-run.
In general, the longer it will be before you retire, the less likely it is that you should pay off your mortgage early. Now you’re ready for Question #8.
#8 – What could you earn if you didn’t pay off your mortgage early?
Most likely, you would invest in some combination of stocks and bonds (or mutual funds that invest in the stocks and bonds). In general, the longer it will be before you retire, the higher your stake can be in stocks.
Stocks tend to earn higher rates in the long run, but are more volatile in the near-term. Financial planners generally recommend that you should subtract your age from 120 (it used to be 100, but we’re living longer) to determine the ideal mix. Then look at historical returns on those assets as a barometer of your expected returns.
Now compare that to your answer from Question #5. It’s highly likely that your answer to Question #8 will be higher than your answer from Question #5. If that’s the case, you’re better off investing the money than paying off your mortgage.
#9 – Will your portfolio support your desired lifestyle?
Even if you’re better off investing, look at your current portfolio. Will it generate enough passive income to completely support your desired lifestyle costs? If so, why take any additional risk? Do the safe thing – get rid of your mortgage debt!
Once your mortgage is paid off, you can use that extra amount every month to build up your portfolio even more (if you want). Or you can just enjoy life – you’ve earned it because you’ve done a great job managing your money!
The advice we’ve given here is general. We recommend that you talk with a financial planner or CPA about your specific situation. Just be sure you find one that doesn’t have a stake in your decision. That way, you’ll know you’re getting the best advice for you, not them!
Pay them a reasonable fee for the advice they give you. It will be worth every penny!