Stop Overthinking Your Decisions

Feeling stuck in your head? On Episode 1198 of The BIGG Success Show, discover how to overcome overthinking, simplify decisions, and create forward momentum in your personal and professional life. Click the player to listen now, or read the blog summary below.

[Podcast Transcript]

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | More

Picture this: You need to make a decision. But your head is spinning from all the options you have before you.

You freeze up. What if you make the wrong choice?

Maybe you should wait. And what happens if something better comes along?

You can feel the eyes of your friends staring at you. You can almost hear them begging you to make a decision. But what will they think of you if you make the wrong decision?

It’s been 15 minutes. And nothing has changed.
You’ve thought about this decision from every angle. Yet you’re still stuck.

Finally…you order your lunch!

Overthinking Isn’t Productive

Overthinking is one of the most common obstacles standing between people and their ultimate BIGG success.
And here’s the tricky part:

Overthinking feels productive. But it rarely produces results.

Successful people don’t eliminate thinking things over. They simply learn when to stop analyzing and start acting.
Let’s talk about how to do exactly that. In this episode we’ll explore:

2 types of overthinking
Why smart people overthink
The solution to overthinking
7 practical ways to stop overthinking

2 types of Overthinking

Overthinking isn’t just thinking a lot. It’s thinking repeatedly without moving toward a decision or action. And there are two common forms of overthinking:

1. Rumination – This type of overthinking focuses on the past. You replay the past over and over. You may ask questions like:

-“Why did I SAY that?”
-“Why did I DO that?”
-“Why didn’t I handle that differently?”

2. Worry – Here, the focus is on the future. You make up problems that may never happen. You may ask questions like:

-“What if this doesn’t work?”
-“What if I fail?”
-“What will people think?”

Both patterns trap your brain in a loop called repetitive negative thinking. Instead of clarity, your brain produces more doubt.

Why Smart People Overthink

Ironically, overthinking often affects ambitious people the most. Why?

Because the traits that drive success can also fuel over-analysis.

Take for example: Perfectionism.
You want to get it right. But perfectionism can turn every decision into a high-stakes event.

Or, think about Responsibility.
You care about outcomes. That sense of responsibility can make you analyze decisions endlessly.

And of course, Intelligence.
It can work against you; smart minds generate more possibilities. Unfortunately, they also generate more “what ifs.”

The result?

Your brain keeps searching for certainty that doesn’t exist.

The Real Solution: Action with Direction

Here’s the key insight:
The cure for overthinking isn’t less thinking.
It’s better structure for your decisions.

When you know where you’re going, when you have a clear vision of the future you want to live, decision-making becomes easier.

Without direction, every choice feels overwhelming. That’s why clarity about your goals and priorities is so powerful. It gives your thinking a destination.

7 Practical Ways to Stop Overthinking

Here are simple strategies you can use immediately to stop overthinking.

1. Notice the Loop

Start by tuning into your thoughts. Ask yourself: “Am I solving this – or just replaying it?”

If you find yourself repeating the same scenario without new insights, you’re likely overthinking.

Awareness is the first step to breaking the cycle.

2. Ask the Action Question

When you feel stuck in thought, ask: “What action would move this forward?”

Even a tiny action breaks the cycle. Examples:

send an email
write a rough plan
ask someone for advice
research one key fact

Action replaces anxiety with momentum.

3. Set Decision Deadlines

Decisions expand to fill the time available. Without a deadline, thinking goes on forever.

Try this guideline:

Small decisions: 5 minutes
Medium decisions: 1 day
BIGG decisions: 1 week

A deadline forces the brain to move forward.

4. Use the 40 / 70 Rule

Colin Powell, Chairperson of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Secretary of State of the United States, popularized a decision-making process called the 40 / 70 rule. It is useful when time is of the essence. He used it for decisions in both his personal world and his professional world.

Here’s how the rule works: When faced with a decision, start gathering information. Realize that 100% is not your goal.

Keep going until you have between 40% and 70% of the amount of information needed. Less than 40% and you may overlook an obvious risk and make a foolish decision. More than 70% and you may miss an opportunity because you keep postponing a decision.

You may be wondering, with a lot of space between 40% and 70%…how do you know when to stop?

Grade a decision by its impact and complexity.

As impact or complexity rise, move closer to 70%. But remember: your goal is to move to a decision in a timely manner.

5. Write It Down

Thoughts feel bigger inside your head. When you write them down, and they exist outside your head, they become manageable. Try:

journaling
pros-and-cons lists
quick brain dumps

Externalizing your thoughts interrupts the loop.

6. Reduce Your Options

Too many choices create mental overload. Limit yourself to three options whenever possible. Fewer choices mean faster decisions.

Follow the retailer’s example: Think good – better – best. The best merchants offer a good product as a base, a better product, and the best product. Think of your three options as a choice between good, better, and best. Then ask: Which is optimal in this situation?

7. Focus on Direction, Not Perfection

Perfection is a moving target. Direction is what matters.

If your actions consistently move you toward a meaningful goal, you’re winning.

One major reason people overthink is simple: They lack a clear framework for their decisions.

If you don’t know your priorities, each opportunity needs careful thought. But when you have clarity about your vision, your mission, your values, and your goals, many decisions become clear.

You stop asking: “What should I do?”
And start asking: “Does this move my life forward?”
That’s a powerful shift.

This is exactly why we created the Life Map Course.

Many people struggle with overthinking – not from a lack of talent or drive, but because they haven’t clarified their priorities yet.

The Life Map process helps you define:

where you want to go
what matters most to you
the major goals that move your life forward
the practical steps to get there

When those pieces are clear, decision-making becomes dramatically easier. Instead of debating every option, you simply ask:
“Does this fit my Life Map?”

If the answer is yes – act.
If the answer is no – move on.

That simple filter eliminates distracting mental noise. Learn more at LifeMapCourse.com.

BIGG Assignment

That brings us to this episode’s BIGG assignment from The Professor

Ready to stop overthinking? Try this simple exercise today.

1. Think of one decision you’ve been overthinking.
2. Write down three possible actions you could take.
3. Set a 24-hour decision deadline.
4. Choose the best option and take the first step immediately.

Don’t wait for perfect clarity. Create momentum. Because every step forward builds momentum, and momentum quiets overthinking.

BIGG Takeaway

Most people believe success comes from perfect thinking.

Wrong!

Success comes from clear direction and consistent action.

Not endless analysis.

Not perfect plans.

Just steady forward movement. And the next thing you know, you reach BIGG success!

Ever feel like your brain has too many tabs open? Join us next time we’ll show you how mental clarity can become a powerful advantage. Subscribe to your favorite podcast channel so you don’t miss it!

Here’s to your BIGG success!

George “The Professor” & Mary-Lynn

Co-Founders, BIGG Success